I've been asked about this a few times, so I'm just posting this so I can point people here instead of trying to explain it each time.
Here's how to verify if a drive is a compatible donor after you've already matched as closely as possible:


Micro Jogs need to be within 300 of each other, preamp vendor and rev should be a match. Headmap should also match, but you can get away with having extra heads if need be. Also keep in mind that preamp vendor and rev is relative to the HDD model number, so if you're using a completely different model they might match here, but be totally different heads.
Here's how to verify if a drive is a compatible donor after you've already matched as closely as possible:


Micro Jogs need to be within 300 of each other, preamp vendor and rev should be a match. Headmap should also match, but you can get away with having extra heads if need be. Also keep in mind that preamp vendor and rev is relative to the HDD model number, so if you're using a completely different model they might match here, but be totally different heads.